Thursday, February 8, 2007

Whistle-Stop.com

It seems like there’s a new candidate throwing their hat into the 2008 election ring every day, lately. But isn’t it a bit early? Is the media cashing in on their lust for a good horserace this early or are the potential candidates doing whatever they can to make the evening news? According to a recent Washington Post article (see link), neither. Most hopefuls this early on are still trying to raise as much money as possible before going into an election that is projected to be the first billion dollar campaign in American history. In fact, John McCain has already spent almost $400,000 in 2006 on gathering aides in New Hampshire and Iowa, while John Kerry had only spent around $4,000 by this time in 2002, according to that same article.

Nothing, however, outweighs the importance of eyeball economy. Many of these candidates have already begun a campaign of sorts on the Internet, like John Edwards, who used YouTube to announce his intention to run for office. Edwards is not alone in his reliance on the Web to get the word out. According to an article on PBS.org (see link) many of the candidates this time around will launch huge online ad campaigns and tap into the Web with similar alacrity that was once reserved for TV commercials.

But will this be enough? Will the immediacy and comfort of watching a political speech, for instance, from home on your computer be enough to squelch those old feelings of participation that can only come from actually attending a rally? Can it eclipse the Romanized stories about Truman’s Whistle Stop Tour we all still carry around from civics class? In an age where you now have to have a billion dollars worth of backing, perhaps a dash of nostalgia wouldn’t hurt.

Washington Post: In Campaign 2008, Candidates Starting Earlier, Spending More
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/06/AR2007020601598.html?referrer=email

PBS.org: 2008 Cadidates Jump Online Early with Blog Ads
http://www.pbs.org/mediashift/2007/01/politicalshift2008_candidates.html

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Too much too early?

Is the news media too pre-occupied with the 2008 presidential election

War coverage

Has the public been kept well-informed by war coverage in the mainstream media?
Prof. Maida Odom

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Victimizing the Victim?

Was apparent kidnapping victim, Shawn Hornbeck, victimized again by media coverage that seemed to blame him for not escaping?

In looking at the recent story concerning Shawn Hornbeck, did the media go to far with the news coverage of the kidnapping? There is a fine ethical line that should not be crossed when dealing with sensitive news topics. In the case of Shawn Hornbeck, the media crossed this line. Michael Devlin held Shawn captive for nearly four years. While immediate news coverage of the kidnapping focused on Michael’s physical and emotional condition; soon after, the media blamed Michael for not being rescued sooner. The television and print media was wrong to point the finger at Michael. They were way too personal in asking Shawn and his family why he did not try to escape. The media should have been more neutral in addressing the issue of kidnappings. They should have done their research and conducted some investigative reporting as to why kidnapped children don’t escape when they have the chance.

In this particular news story, it seems evident that the media was asking all the wrong questions. They were asking the questions that their paying audience wanted to hear not the questions that would help Michael and his family. They did not truly take Michael and his family’s well being into account. The journalists covering this story should have let the dust clear and allow the trial to be resolved before asking this interrogating question. However, blaming Michael for not escaping helped to increase newspaper and television ratings. The media created a whole new story instead of truly focusing on the recent kidnapping.

There are many alternate ways the media could have covered this kidnapping without asking Michael why didn’t he escape. Journalists should have focused on previous kidnappings and analyzed the issue of escape. In addition, the timing of this particular question was very inappropriate. As mentioned before, the media should have been more sensitive to the Hornbeck family. It may have seemed like the media was trying to cover all angles of the story and be objective but this is not the case. For example, would it have been appropriate to ask victims of the hurricane Katrina disaster why didn’t they try to escape the storm? In times of crisis, the media should strive to be on the victims’ side and not create distress and controversy

In conclusion, the media industry needs to severely reevaluate their ethical standards. Unfortunately, corporations that are only concerned about profit and viewer ratings control the journalism industry. While objective and ethical journalism may seem like an unattainable ideal, is not impossible to achieve. It should be interesting to see how the media responds to the next major American crisis, whether it be a war, natural disaster, or kidnapping.


Victor Montoro
BTMM grad student (spring 07)

Stockholm Syndrome is what deserves press

Shawn Hornbeck’s parents may have done something foolish, they may have not. They were basking in the afterglow of the fruition of a four year pursuit of their boy and then, though already in the garden of Eden, they partook of the deadliest fruit: Oprah. Daytime television’s first lady looked more like the Pied Piper leading a mob of journalists all with two scorching questions—why didn’t he leave if he had several chances, and was Shawn Hornbeck sexually abused?
The answer to the latter has finally been aired thanks to Oprah, on national TV, by his parents. Many people’s response has been to cast them into the 7th layer of hell, but in light of the fact that many details are still being rung out by the police, being first to say that there was abuse may have seemed like a dignified way to go about breaking the news. Since that airing of “Oprah” much of the above-of-the-fold fanfare has subsided. Because now, things have gotten a bit too sticky, no one wants to know why he didn’t leave because in light of the sexual abuse that has been aired, the only question that’s left to ask is: was the abuse somehow consensual? And no one wants ask that.
But according to many experts on the Stockholm syndrome, if there is a need for survival and a captor presents himself as the only means to that end, then eventually strange, and incredibly strong bonds will begin to form between captor and his victim. This delves far too deep into the reaches of the human mind and many media outlets simply don’t want to be weighed down with explaining why and how such a bizarre thing could happen. But according to mental-health-matters.com Stockholm syndrome can be as common as an abusive boyfriend or an addiction to cigarettes. Media avoiding of the topic (Oprah, I’m looking at you) leaves all of us to wonder and allow our imaginations to run away with ourselves. Not to mention the imaginations of the high school classmates the Hornbeck boy will be joining.
‘Why didn’t he run away?’ seems not so pressing a question as why hasn’t the media turned Stockholm syndrome into the next ADD?
Carrie Compton

Victimizing the Victim?

A respectable journalist will approach a story like Shawn Hornbeck’s with caution. The extent to which he will probe and investigate, reveal and speculate, will depend heavily on how he balances his aim to address the public’s curiosity and his desire to avoid invading the family’s privacy. But how far can a journalist go without access to the source himself? In this media circus, the victim’s family perhaps plays a larger role than we are willing to admit.

Hornbeck’s family appeared on "Oprah" less than a week after he returned home. Was Oprah going too far when she asked his parents if they thought he had been sexually abused? That was for them to say. By answering her question—they both said yes—they were complicit in the media invasion.

To suggest that Hornbeck’s family was played by the media, confused—maybe even intoxicated—by all of the attention would be ignoring the complexity of the situation. It was media coverage of Shawn’s disappearance, after all, that helped them find their son. When Elizabeth Smart, a Utah teenager who was abducted from her home in 2002, was found nine months later, there was no shortage of headlines about the case. The frenzy was fed perhaps in part by Smart’s camera-comfortable parents, who spoke openly to the press (during at least one press conference) about their daughter’s return. The attention eventually died down, but the family has not retreated back to their world of anonymity. Elizabeth’s father, Edward Smart, just recently appeared on “Good Morning America Weekend Edition” to comment on the Hornbeck event.

The victims and their families must learn that they play an integral role in protecting themselves from media exposure. Staying out of the limelight until the next sensational story hits is a small sacrifice for those who value their privacy.

Rachel Healy
TJR Spring 2007

Victimizing the Victim?

The case of Shawn Hornbeck’s kidnapping and eventual rescue on January 12 has prompted many interesting questions about the responsibility of reporters and of journalism as a whole.
Since Shawn was found, the media has not let up on play-by-plays of everything from his reunion with his parents to how he will make up the four years he lost to the hands of his kidnapper. Every parent with a missing child hopes for an ending like this – that their child will be found, safe and alive. However, the media changed its story from “the lost boy is found!” to “why didn’t he get out sooner?” in a matter of days. Instead of simply being thankful that he was found, along with another kidnapped boy, reporters and pundits immediately began questioning why Shawn hadn’t tried harder to escape his captor. ‘Why didn’t he call police,’ they asked after it became obvious he had been left alone while his kidnapper worked at the local pizza shop. If he had been kidnapped against his will, the wondered, why hadn’t he told a neighbor? Unfortunately, even more details emerged that the media decided to use in their case of trying to prove that Shawn could have escaped, but did not. For one, Shawn recently posted a comment on the website his parents constructed as a tool to help find him. Why didn’t he write where he was? Why didn’t he tell his captor’s name? Just yesterday, various media outlets broke the news that Shawn had dated a young woman during the time he was kidnapped. Some have asked, why didn’t he tell her he had been kidnapped years before? Shawn even ran into police ten months ago, who questioned him about a stolen bicycle, and he never asked for help.
Plenty of experts have noted that kidnapping victims become mentally bound to their captors, citing examples of other victims who felt indebted to the very person who took their life away.
But none of us were there. How are we to know what kind of violent, emotional, or sexual tactics Shawn’s captor used to scare him? We must not forget that Shawn was a highly impressionable 11 year-old at the time of his kidnapping. Some reports have stated that the kidnapper told Shawn his parents did not want him anymore. If this was the case, is it really so hard to understand why Shawn wouldn’t attempt to get away?
I think there is another issue that comes into play in the case of Shawn Hornbeck, and that is one of gender. Did the media raise such questions when Elizabeth Smart was kidnapped, held against her will and then found after almost a year? If my memory serves me correctly, people did speculate on the details of her kidnapping, but much later and not in the mainstream media. Was Shawn accused of not trying to escape his captor simply because he is a boy who ‘should’ have figured out a way to get away? Since Elizabeth was a young girl, did people take sympathy and see her as more of a victim than the way they currently see Shawn?
These questions are not to be taken lightly when such a serious event as a kidnapping is the topic of conversation around the water cooler this January. Perhaps it would serve us all well to think about ourselves and our loved ones in this kind of situation – maybe then we will go a little easier on each other.

Maureen Fisher
TJR Spring 2007